![]() |
My friend took this photo when we were at a coffee shop one day. This couple was just sitting down together talking and laughing over the books they were reading. (Photo: Abbie Mills) |
Perhaps it was only because of my slight obsession with photography that the buzzword "snapshot" caught my attention during class that day, but whatever the case I think that Virginia Woolf's writing style and photojournalism share several similarities.
As we learned in Woolf's essays, she thinks that a novel isn't a novel unless it is intensely focused on the characters in the novel. She expresses her annoyance at Edwardian writers by saying
"They have looked very powerfully, searchingly, and sympathetically out of the window; at factories, at Utopias, even at the decoration and upholstery of the carriage; but never at her, never at life, never at human nature"
This is a beautiful picture of street lamps in Romania, but it doesn't tell much of a story. (Photo: Nat'l Geographic) |
"Life is not a series of gig lamps symmetrically arranged; but a luminous halo, a semi-transparent envelope surrounding us from the beginning of consciousness to the end," says Woolf in another essay on writing fiction.
Photojournalism recognizes this too. Life isn't an artistically arranged bouquet of flowers, and it isn't edited to perfection either. Life is about the people on this planet, the decisions they make, the things they create, and the interactions they share.
I love this photo of a family dinner where the relatives are laughing and joking with each other around the table. Photos like this capture the emotions involved in everyday life and then you, as the viewer, also share in those emotions. (Photo: Julian Smith) |
Photojournalism captures human activity in a way that can both tell a story and challenge the viewer. Photojournalism is all about capturing the action--emotions, expressions, and movements. The instructor for a photojournalism class that I took during Agora Days once said, “Look out for and capture the moments--that’s what makes photojournalism interesting.”
And indeed, it is what makes photojournalism interesting. For those captured moments are moments that reveal our character and our humanity. Photos like these can create bonds of recognition between people who have never even seen each other because many times we share more similarities than we first assume. There's something about being able to understand where another person is coming from that allows us to respect each other so much more.
When I see this photo I get a feeling of happy contentment. Perhaps it's because seeing this embrace reminds me of hugs that I have shared with people that I care about. Remembering those hugs establishes a connection between my life and the actions of those in this picture (Photo: Nat'l Geographic). |
Photojournalism also gives us glimpses into the darker sides of human nature with pictures of war and suffering. These pictures make the struggles of people all around the world all the more real to us.
This picture of a mother and her son in the aftermath of the atomic bomb on Hiroshima is a solemn reminder of the unrelenting pain of war. (Photo: Life Magazine) |
Woolf's obsession with uncovering human nature to make more realistic art (in her case the art of the novel) could have made her a great photojournalist, but I'm glad she stuck with writing.
Although two different mediums, one writing and the other photography, both Woolf and photojournalists have the responsibility to accurately portray human emotion and character through their art for their respective audiences. Through both photojournalism and Woolf's novels, we learn what it means to be a part of this vast world full of unique human beings.
This is a really interesting and original analogy--surprising, since most often we talk about Woolf as an *internally* focused writer of character rather than an externally focused "realist." But you make some great points about how good photojournalism indeed can depict "internal" emotional states by freezing people in the midst of social behaviors. I think that the "photographic" aspect of Woolf's prose is especially evident in the outdoor urban sections, where Clarissa (and others) are walking through the city: in fact, I always use the filmic term "montage" to talk about the second section of the novel, where the various perspectives are all tied together by the passing motor-car and the skywriting plane. Woolf's narrator is like the inconspicuous street photographer, snapping images of each of these people as they watch the plane or the car.
ReplyDeleteI love that you wrote about photography, first. Second, I also thought that the way she was able to jump from character to character and give them all real depth was impressive. I guess this is kind of why I like writing. I did photography for a while, but found it limiting in a way. I couldn't make other people understand and feel the way I wanted them to. Then again, that's one of the benefits of visual art. Everyone has their own unique opinion and feelings. But with writing, you can't make people see what you see. Everyone has their own imagination and fills in the details in their own way. Within the lines or outside of them, I also loved the idea of 'snapshots'. They're short stories that have more meaning than words or pictures. Woolf dose it in such a way that says 'this is a person's life' and just lays it all out in front of you like unedited thoughts and feelings.
ReplyDeleteKathryn, I love your connection between photography and Woolf's writing style. I'm no photography expert by any means, but as a casual viewer I think one of the best things about photography is that, even though you can only see the surface, emotions and interpretations shine through, reflecting their own minds. Just as each character's view of Clarissa not only reveals an aspect of Clarissa but also a bit of themselves. So it's like Woolf is taking a picture of all her characters taking pictures of each other. (Woah.)
ReplyDeleteAlso, I like the "Life isn't an artistically arranged bouquet of flowers" line. Again, great job!
Wow, this is a great insight into how Mrs. Dalloway gives you little moments of people's lives, and I completely agree with you. Whenever I go somewhere particularly beautiful on vacation, I am tempted to take lots of photos of gorgeous sunsets and flowers, but when I look at the pictures back at home, it's most fun to look at the ones that had people in them. Pictures with people are far more interesting--whether they are photographs, drawings, or paintings. Portraits are my main focus artistically because people are so much more interesting than anything else. I think Woolf really gets this, and, like you said, she explores human emotion deeply and portrays it in a startlingly accurate way, almost like a photograph. Most authors can't do that!
ReplyDelete